QUOTE(Redbird)
Scot's experience would seem to indicate the K&N resticted flow from what I know. Less air, rich condition, worsened by an increase in altitude. Yes there's other variables and it may not be that clear cut, but if a bike is running lean and you give it less air, it gets better, not worse. No one has explained to me how the reverse can be true- and I'm listening if you want to make that clear to me. This isn't a "bullshit, you're wrong" type of statement, it's a "please point out the flaw in my logic" type of statement. And again, it's more anecdotal evidence, anyway. As Scot said, it may have been as simple as the thing was over-oiled from the factory, and it's one guy's experience on one bike. But I wouldn't dismiss it out of hand like you seem to want to do.
Bottom line is I'm not sold on K&N being any kind of performance upgrade on the XX. Re-usability, yes, but I hate "servicing" airfilters, so I'll stick with the stocker myself.
Well... here I'll try...
Good morning Tim...
First off you have to think of air as being elastic, stretchable, compressable, etc. Fuel on the other hand is not.
The first part of a carberator works, by increasing the speed of the air through the bore or mouth of the carberator, this also creates a small pressure rise in this area, which can be parcitially directed into the float bowl buy the pilot jet.
The second part of the carberator is the throat, were it gets bigger. As the air fills this bigger area, it wants to slow down, but can't. So it creates a pressure drop which is what grabs the heavy fuel and carries it along into the intake tract.
But there is the whole problem with tunning carberators, that low pressure varies all the time. It changes with every RPM the motor increases and in also changes with how much air pressure is pushing on the mouth of the carberator.
Every air filter is a restictor plate to some degree.
But back to the problem, so as you increase the amount of air pressure on the mouth of the carberator, and increase the amount of air that goes through the carberator, create create a greater Low pressure difference in the throat. Now at first one would think that it would then grab more fuel... because it has more suction. But that's not always the case. If the carberator was tuned properly to start with it will cause an even greater lean out, because the Jets are not going to allow any more fuel to pass through to get picked up.
So... I'm guessing (which I hate to do, but I will) that Involutes bike was never propperly tunned in the first place. which means his fuel ratio is already off for his elevation. So maybe this is where I probably screwwed up in the first place... I was assumeing... I should do that... I don't know if his bike is running rich or lean.
Now if his Jets were original too big for his elevation... then the oposite will occure and the motor will go too rich. It's a good rule of thumb to drop one jet size for every 2,500 feet of elevation. Since he is running at almost 5K feet, he is already running jets 2 sizes too big, if he still has the stock jets in, and probably already running a little rich.
Tunning carberators is not always fun, because first you must tune it propperly for it's conditions, elevation, motor, RPM, Baro, humidity, etc....
then you must tune it again for any changes you make in terms of Mods., exhaust, air cleaner, cam, etc.
As for Involute... you have one more test you could do....
but first off you need to get your bike adjusted for it's altitude, then...
on the same day...
1) Run the bike with the stock air filter.
2) pull it and put the K&N in, run it and notice any change.
3) remove the air filter all together, run it and see if it feels more like with the stock filter in... or more like with the K&N in.
If running without a air cleaner feels more like stock then you could conclude that the K&N is restrictive.
But if running without the aircleaner feel more like running with the K&N, then you could coclude that the stock filter is more restrictive.
Now.... I have seen the diference in flow on a makeshift flowmeter, between the stock and K&N filter, and can tell you the stock filter is alot more restrictive.
I hope all that helps... ?
PS. Tim... I'm also glad and pist at the same time, that I have a FI bike. Glad because I don't have to pull the bike apart in order to adjust the fuel, as I did with carbs.
But I'm also pist because I had to spend an extra $600 too be able to propperly adjust the FI system. :wink:
So just remember air is elastic.... and that changes everything.